A women in Bapla, Burkina Faso, standing next to the well she dug herself, but which has dried up.
Photo: Manon Koningstein/ IWMI

Moving from water problems to water solutions in a climate-challenged world

As we understand more about the challenges posed by global warming, it has become widely accepted that water is the principal medium through which society feels the climate-related stresses. But we have an opportunity to flip water from being a challenge into an opportunity, our authors maintain.

The beginning of life on Earth has been linked to water. Modern humans (Homo sapiens) have inhabited this planet for some 300,000 years, most of that time as hunter-gatherers. Some 10,000 years ago, when people increasingly adopted an agrarian way of life, humans started establishing permanent settlements. All of the early civilisations were established close to large water bodies – rivers, lakes and the sea. About 70 per cent of our planet’s surface area as well as of human bodies consists of water. Therefore, water is literally life.

Water underpins nearly everything we do: agriculture, industries, energy production, recreation, drinking, cooking and hygiene. It is also the foundation of every ecosystem on the planet. As such, the management of water cuts across sectors and international boundaries. Furthermore, cities are growing population hotspots, and the increasing populations and changing socio-economic expectations will impact water. The management of water also connects themes such as governance, equity, natural resources management, climate change and economic development. This fluidity of water requires equally fluid management systems.

How much water do we have, and can we access it?

The oceans hold about 97.5 per cent of the Earth’s water resources as saline water. Therefore, only 2.5 per cent of all the water on the planet is fresh, making it a relatively limited resource. Furthermore, of this fresh water, around 68.7 per cent is frozen as glaciers and ice caps. And 30.1 per cent is difficult to access as it is stored below the surface as groundwater. This means only 1.2 per cent of all fresh water on the planet is accessible as surface water through lakes, wetlands, rivers, streams, soil moisture or biological water. The hydrological cycle basically consists of flows of water between various stores or storages (e.g. the atmosphere, oceans, snow and ice, rivers, lakes, reservoirs, wetlands, soils and aquifers).

Water availability calculations are based on the water resources available per spatial unit (e.g. basin or country) and time (daily, monthly, seasonal, annual or even longer time scales). The mismatch between water availability and demand leads to water scarcity issues and adds stress to societies. There are wide variations in water availability vs. demand between the different regions world-wide (see Figure). Water available in a particular country might or might not be generated within its own borders. For instance, upstream countries like Bhutan, Nepal, Ethiopia or China generate basically all their water within their geographical boundaries, while downstream countries like Bangladesh, Egypt, parts of Vietnam or the Netherlands receive the vast majority of their water from across their geographical boundaries.

In certain places, such as uplands in mountainous areas, water availability might be low even though a large river flows just a few hundred metres away in the valley below. If the upland areas have the economic means to access the river water through pumping, they do not have water scarcity issues. Similarly, groundwater or even shallow groundwater might be available, but lacking infrastructure to pump groundwater and necessary capacity, many countries face what is called economic water scarcity. This is especially true in many areas in Africa and South and South-East Asia.

Water and food systems – intrinsically linked

Agriculture is the largest water user, responsible for about 70 per cent of all freshwater withdrawals, most of which is used for irrigation. The 2018 United Nations World Water Development Report forecasts a 60 per cent increase in food demand by 2050, which will require more arable land and intensification of production and will also translate into more use of water. The recent EAT-Lancet report on sustainable diets makes clear that the way we currently produce our food and what we consume is becoming one of our greatest challenges, with the health of people and the environment depending on finding solutions. More than 820 million people have insufficient food, and many more consume an unhealthy diet that contributes to obesity, premature death and diseases. At the same time, global food production severely impacts climate stability and ecosystem integrity and constitutes the single largest driver of environmental degradation, climate change and the stability of the Earth system.

Agricultural systems are dependent both on hydrology and on related institutions, i.e. systems of governance that support sustainable and wise use of land and water. Sustainable, efficient and affordable water management is key to the transformation of the global food and agricultural systems. There is no agriculture without water. Thus sustainable water management is foundational for producing more food with less resources – referred to as sustainable agricultural intensification (SAI). Furthermore, water is a major contributor to the environmental footprint of agricultural practices. Examples include overdraft from rivers and groundwater leading to unsustainable depletion and transportation of pollutants to adjacent water bodies.  
According to estimates by Gosling and Arnell, by 2050, up to three billion people may be living with increased water scarcity because of climate change, which is reconfiguring the water system. The fifth Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assessment reports with medium confidence that global surface temperatures in 2016 – 2035 will be 0.3°C to 0.7°C higher relative to 1986 – 2005. Towards the end of the 21st century, global surface temperature is projected with high confidence to exceed 1.5°C relative to temperatures in the 1800s. Of course various levels of anthropogenic emission scenarios give us different numbers, underscoring the need for action on emissions.

How climate change affects water availability

The IPCC warns that although projected changes particularly in precipitation are not uniform globally, extreme precipitation events will become more intense and frequent in many regions. Global warming has been linked to a wide range of water-related risks that also impact indirectly or directly on agricultural production – including animal husbandry and fisheries – and hence on food production and food security:

  • intensification of the global water cycle leading to increasingly extreme events such as floods, droughts and tropical storms;
  • changing variability in seasonal patterns of rainfall, onset and length of seasons, heat waves and extreme cold spells;
  • less snow cover, loss of glacier ice and changes in river runoff impacting water availability;
  • sea-level rise leading to salt water intrusion in coastal systems;
  • lower water quality because higher temperatures strongly influence increases in organic matter, nitrate and phosphorus levels in river water;
  • increased water pollution, because of more frequent extreme events and higher loads of sediments, nutrients, dissolved organic carbon, pathogens, pesticides and salt;
  • significant changes in river flow patterns and hence impacts for the habitat of aquatic biota;
  • impacts on groundwater availability. For instance, groundwater storage in the Murray-Darling basin declined substantially from 2000 to 2007 in response to a sharp reduction in recharge during the 1996 – 2010 Millennium Drought in Southern Australia.

As we understand more about the challenges posed by global warming, it has become widely accepted that water is the principal medium through which society feels the climate-related stresses. Smith et al. have identified water as the “teeth and claws” of climate change. But we have an opportunity to flip water from being a challenge into an opportunity. The world’s community of water professionals largely share the view that water is not just a risk but is also the key to climate change adaptation. The world has a chance to align policy and implementation for water and climate change adaptation agendas around water resilience. This close connection between adaptation and water resources management has been increasingly recognised, and some even called the COP 25 – the 2019 United Nations Climate Change Conference – a ‘water COP’ because of the wide-ranging discussions on water-related climate issues.

ANALYSING HISTORICAL DATA IS NO LONGER ENOUGH
For at least two centuries, the underlying assumption for managing water variability and extremes has been that we can assess future weather patterns, predict water risks, or design infrastructure, by analysing the historical data. Climate change and other environmental changes have invalidated this assumption – we cannot predict and plan for the future based on past trends anymore. Flood management, for instance, has traditionally used past records to determine parameters such as 1 in 100 years flood peaks.  However, as we can expect the frequency and severity of flood events to increase because of climate change and often also in connections with other environmental changes (land use changes, urbanisation, channelling of rivers, etc.), risk calculations from the past are not usable. For example, precipitation levels during Hurricane Harvey in the Houston, Texas area in the USA in 2017, surpassed a return period for three-day extreme precipitation of 1 in 1,000 years for most locales and in one city, 1 in 9,000 years. Similar patterns are emerging for droughts. Cape Town’s “Day Zero” drought that ended in 2018 has been estimated as a 1 in 300 years event as documented by 400 years of historical records. When two large tropical cyclones, Idai and Kenneth, hit South-eastern Africa in 2019, it was, according to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), the first time on record that two storms of such intensity struck Mozambique in the same season.

Integrated approaches that go with the flow

The direct impacts of climate change on water will be effectively “multiplied” via the effects on the other sectors linked together in the water-energy-food-environment-livelihood nexus. So it’s clear that we need integrated approaches. Improved water management options from farm-level water management to basin level, if done appropriately, will not only reduce current water-related risks and insecurities but also mitigate many of the potential negative impacts of climate change. Increasing the adaptive capacity and simultaneously enhancing water, food and energy security are often among the ‘ripple effects’ of improved water management and increased resilience of society.

To harness the climate adaptation potential of water – and minimise the climate-related risks – we need integrated management systems. Several concepts, such as the Integrated Water Resources Management, the Water-Energy-Food nexus and the Water Security frameworks, have been promoting various integrative and holistic approaches for basin water management. There have also been many initiatives, such as the establishment of river basin authorities, to introduce related processes around the globe that promote integrated river basin management and development. For example in the European Union, Integrated River Basin Management (IRBM) is fostered by two Framework Directives, which were established to realise sustainable, integrated and effective river basin management. The first one is the Water Framework Directive from 2000 with the objective to assess water quality and achieve a good status for all water bodies. Furthermore, the Food Risk Management Directive deals with the assessment and management of flood risks. Despite these examples, the actual management of water in most countries, and especially in the Global South, is still very fragmented and sectoral. This leads to inefficiency, un-sustainability and, under certain conditions, even to conflicts.

A holistic approach to water management is needed

In recent decades, adaptation to climate change impacts has become one key development agenda often also included in national plans and policies. There remains, however, a big gap in translating these global and national policies to local action plans and services. Furthermore, coordination between management and governance systems is a key challenge to ensure that water resources management is done with the purview of balancing benefits across various sectors, stakeholders and future climate risks. Here, it is important for water resources resiliency and adaptation planning to consider the varying levels of climate vulnerability in a basin given existing structural inequities in gender, income level, class, race, ethnicity, etc.

Above all in the Global South, achieving water sustainability faces a wide range of challenges. Often, data and comprehensive analysis of water resources are lacking at basin/country levels, and development planning and management is usually sectoral (‘silo mentality’) and fragmented. In addition, current governance structures and processes do not facilitate reaching a shared vision to develop a basin/country sustainably regarding water. And there is lack of understanding of the direction and magnitude of future changes and risks related to water and all its implications for the environment, society and economy.

Globally, the 17 Sustainable Development Goals with their 169 associated targets are demanding for holistic and integrated development. The shift in focus from merely growing productivity to also considering equity, social justice, environmental health and all other aspects for sustainability has brought development discourses to a crossroads. New targets and indicators are changing the ways success is measured. Integrated water management will play a key role in the implementation of all SDGs because of the interdependencies between many of the goals and targets. Therefore, understanding and managing trade-offs well will be essential.

We are moving into a world where rather than managing water for individual sectors, such as health and sanitation, we must integrate these with other needs such as water for irrigation, hydropower, industry, and ecosystems. This integration must be across multiple users and uses.

Future water resources management and development should ideally include all sectoral demands and achieve various societal objectives in a balanced way, under a wide range of plausible futures (robust) and incorporate adaptive and flexible solutions. And we need to support these solutions through enabling governance structures and policies that allow us to navigate our water resources challenges in turbulent waters. Our survival depends on this.
 

Luna Bharati is a Principal Researcher at the International Water Management Institute (IWMI) and is based at the Center for Development Research (ZEF) at Bonn University, Germany.
Stefan Uhlenbrook is Strategic Program Director for Water, Food and Ecosystems at the International Water Management Institute in Colombo, Sri Lanka.
Contact: L.bharati(at)cgiar.org

The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the coordinated research programme Water, Land and Ecosystems (WLE) of CGIAR. We would like to thank Adam Hunt of WLE, IWMI for his comments and editorial work on an earlier version of the manuscript.

References and further reading:

Evers, M. (2016). Integrative river basin management: Challenges and methodologies within the German planning system. Environmental Earth Science 75 (14), 215.
doi: 10.1007/s12665016-5871-3

Gleick PH (1996). Water resources. In: Encyclopedia of Climate and Weather. pp 817–823.

Gosling, S.N., and Arnell, N.W. (2016). "A global assessment of the impact of climate change on water scarcity." Climatic Change 134(3): 371–385.
doi:10.1007/s10584-013-0853-x.

Smith, D. Mark; Matthews, J. H.; Bharati, Luna; Borgomeo, Edoardo; McCartney, Matthew; Mauroner, A.; Nicol, Alan; Rodriguez, D.; Sadoff, Claudia; Suhardiman, Diana; Timboe, I.; Amarnath, Giriraj; Anisha, N. (2019). Adaptation’s thirst: accelerating the convergence of water and climate action. Background paper prepared for the 2019 report of the Global Commission on Adaptation. Rotterdam, Netherlands: Global Commission on Adaptation (GCA) 42p.

WWAP (UNESCO World Water Assessment Programme)/UN-Water (2019). The United Nations World Water Development Report 2019: Leaving No One Behind. Paris, UNESCO.

World Water Assessment Programme (2018): The United Nations World Water Development Report 2018 (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization, New York, United States) www.unwater.org/publications/world-water-development-report-2018/.

Willet, W., Rockström, J., Loken, B. (2019). Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT– Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems. Lancet. 2019; 393: 447-492.

Cookie settings